"Oh forgive me; I was using common sense; I should stop that or I'll never comprehend this persons logic..."

This person's logic is...twisted, to say the least. He's trotted out every argument, from "Emily's brashness is a legitimate character flaw, and just because no one points it out and she never suffers consequences for it doesn't mean it isn't unintentional!" to "if you condemn this fic, you're supporting book-banning and segregation" to "Well it's realistic, because kids are such brats today that the girls are angels!" to "it wasn't unreasonable of Hermione to ask them to wear underwear, they were justified in throwing a fit because she broke her promise to them!" to "I'm sure nudists touch their kids in private areas just like clothed people do". (O_o, I say on that last one)